Overview of the San Diego OnlyFans Model Murder Case Involving Fetish Practices

Image
Aimie Parpia
Updated 10:32 PM, September 12, 2025

Overview of San Diego OnlyFans Model Murder Case

In a startling legal development in San Diego, Calif., OnlyFans model Michaela Brashaye Rylaarsdam faces murder charges stemming from a fatal fetish encounter. The drama unfolded after the death of 56-year-old Michael Dale in 2023, with the ensuing legal proceedings attracting widespread attention.

Details from the Fatal Encounter

The incident, which led to Dale's death, reportedly involved a BDSM session at his residence near San Diego, for which he had paid Rylaarsdam over $11,000. Escondido Police Department's Detective Chris Zack pointed to comprehensive evidence including text messages that confirmed Dale's consent to and payment for the activities. During the initial hearing, Dale's roommate, Andrew Smith, described hearing distressing pleas from Dale to end the session before ultimately calling 911.

Evidence and Charges

Further investigation revealed videos on Rylaarsdam's phone showing her tightening restraints and interacting with the camera, with Dale appearing unresponsive in the background. Following these discoveries, the San Diego County Medical Examiner's Office ruled Dale's death as homicide, caused primarily by asphyxiation from a plastic bag over his head. Aggravating factors noted were Dale’s elevated blood alcohol levels and pre-existing health conditions.

Legal Proceedings and Defense

At her preliminary hearing, defense arguments highlighted Rylaarsdam’s efforts to resuscitate Dale and wait for medical assistance without fleeing the scene. Despite these claims, Rylaarsdam was detained at Las Colinas Detention Facility without bail. The arraignment is set for September 27, where the full details of the case will be further examined.

Next Steps in the Trial

As the trial approaches, both prosecution and defense are preparing to delve into the minutiae of the circumstances surrounding Dale's death. Legal experts and the public alike are keenly watching the developments, as the case tests the boundaries of consent and responsibility within potentially lethal fetish practices.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

Aimie Parpia, based in sunny San Diego, California, is RhyteIt's go-to expert in social media strategy for adult content creators. With a sharp eye for digital trends and a deep understanding of audience engagement, Aimie crafts tailored social media strategies that boost visibility and drive results. She’s passionate about helping creators establish a strong brand presence across platforms, guiding them in navigating the complex social media landscape to build lasting success in the adult content industry.