Overview of Class-Action Lawsuit Against OnlyFans for Deceptive Practices

Image
Jane Kim
Updated 04:36 PM, April 01, 2025

Overview of Class-Action Lawsuit Against OnlyFans

Two former subscribers, M. Brunner and J. Fry from Illinois, have filed a class-action lawsuit against the digital content platform OnlyFans, alleging deception through impersonation by third-party agencies. The complaint centers on their belief that they were directly interacting with content creators, rather than agencies acting on the creators' behalf.

Details of the Allegations

The plaintiffs argue they were misled into paying for personal interactions, including direct messages and video clips, under the impression these communications were with the actual creators themselves. Highlighting the scale of this issue, they pointed out that some creators have up to 700,000 fans, making it dubious that such individualized attention could be sustained without help. This realization prompted both Brunner and Fry to state they would have reconsidered their subscriptions had they known about the involvement of agencies.

Impact of Alleged Impersonation on Subscribers

The lawsuit criticizes OnlyFans for potentially prioritizing profit over authentic user engagement. Specifically, J. Fry noted his initial interest in OnlyFans was to share culinary content and engage in casual interactions with models, but inconsistencies in the received messages fueled doubts about their authenticity.

Current Status of the Case

While the lawsuit alleges deceptive practices by OnlyFans, direct evidence of agency involvement in fan interactions has not been provided in the legal documents. As of the latest updates, OnlyFans has not yet responded to the allegations presented in this ongoing legal matter.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

• • •
Jane Kim is a Louisville-based reporter for RhyteIt, specializing in building and nurturing online communities for adult content creators. Kim offers insights into community management, fan engagement, and networking strategies that help creators cultivate loyal followings on platforms like OnlyFans and Fansly. Her expertise empowers creators to foster vibrant, supportive online spaces that enhance brand loyalty and audience connection.