OnlyFans Legal Challenge on Impersonation Issues - Class Action Lawsuit Details

Image
Aimie Parpia
Updated 10:34 AM, April 08, 2025

OnlyFans Legal Challenge on Third-Party Impersonations

Two residents of Illinois, identified as M. Brunner and J. Fry, have filed a class-action lawsuit against OnlyFans' parent entities, Fenix Internet LLC and Fenix International Limited. They accuse the popular content subscription service of permitting models to employ third-party services for impersonating them in interactions with subscribers. This legal move aims to spotlight and address concerns about authenticity and deceptive practices on digital content platforms.

Details of the Allegations

The core complaint by Brunner and Fry centers around their belief that they were misled about who they were communicating with on OnlyFans. They assert that had they been aware that their communications were not with the actual content creators but rather third-party representatives, they would not have opted for paid subscriptions. The issue surfaced after Fry detected inconsistencies in the messages he received, leading him to question the authenticity of the interaction.

OnlyFans' Response to Impersonation Claims

The lawsuit highlights the broader implications of such alleged practices, suggesting that OnlyFans might be indirectly enriching itself by not clearly demarcating the roles of third parties involved with its content creators. In a previous statement to Cosmopolitan, an OnlyFans spokesperson clarified that any third-party collaborators, including photographers, videographers, talent managers, or agencies, do not represent OnlyFans nor are they affiliated with the platform.

Legal and Consumer Implications

The action taken by Brunner and Fry seeks to enforce accountability and ensure transparency on the OnlyFans platform, aiming to protect subscriber interests from potentially misleading practices. The case underscores the growing scrutiny and demand for clear communication standards in online platforms where direct subscriber and content creator interactions are a fundamental part of the service.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

• • •
Aimie Parpia, based in sunny San Diego, California, is RhyteIt's go-to expert in social media strategy for adult content creators. With a sharp eye for digital trends and a deep understanding of audience engagement, Aimie crafts tailored social media strategies that boost visibility and drive results. She’s passionate about helping creators establish a strong brand presence across platforms, guiding them in navigating the complex social media landscape to build lasting success in the adult content industry.