OnlyFans Creator Charged with Second-Degree Murder in Fetish Encounter

Image
Jaime Rincon
Updated 10:33 PM, March 18, 2025

OnlyFans Creator Charged with Second-Degree Murder

Michaela Brashaye Rylaarsdam, a 31-year-old OnlyFans creator, faces second-degree murder charges after a fatal incident during a recorded fetish encounter resulted in the death of 55-year-old Michael Dale nearly two years ago. Dale, according to reports, was suffocated and subsequently declared brain-dead the following day. He was later removed from life support, culminating in his death.

Details of the Incident

The authorities found Dale with his wrists bound while his fingers and legs were wrapped with duct tape and plastic, along with a plastic bag over his head. An affidavit suggests he could not free himself and had not consented to the obstructed breathing or the use of the restraints applied during the encounter. Rylaarsdam was arrested after turning over her phone, which contained multiple videos displaying Dale struggling to breathe. These revealed disturbing scenes of Dale's mouth duct-taped and his face and head covered with more plastic wrap. Footage shortly before Dale became unresponsive showed Rylaarsdam engaged in a sexual act, part of content purportedly being created for her OnlyFans page.

Court Proceedings and Defense

Rylaarsdam has pleaded not guilty at her initial court appearance in Vista Superior Court. Her defense, led by attorney David Cohen, stated that there was no intent to kill, framing the incident as a tragic accident during an isolated fetish act. Cohen emphasized that Rylaarsdam acted responsibly once she recognized the severity of the situation by calling 911, although this was approximately four hours post-incident. Upon their arrival, officers witnessed Rylaarsdam performing CPR on the unresponsive Dale.

Impact and Legal Outlook

The case continues to develop with both legal and public scrutiny. As Rylaarsdam's background as an OnlyFans creator becomes a focal point, the utilization of digital content in criminal investigations comes under spotlight, noting the complexities of consent and accountability in digitally mediated sexual activities.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

• • •
Jaime Rincon is a Memphis-based reporter for RhyteIt, specializing in fan communication strategies for adult content creators. Rincon provides expert insights on fostering strong connections with fans, optimizing engagement, and maintaining meaningful interactions on platforms like OnlyFans and Fansly. His work empowers creators to enhance fan loyalty and grow their online communities through effective, personalized communication practices.