OnlyFans Creator Charged with Murder in Fatal Fetish Encounter

Image
Carla Rosa
Updated 10:37 PM, March 19, 2025

OnlyFans Creator Charged with Second-Degree Murder in Fatal Fetish Encounter

In a shocking incident in Escondido, California, Michaela Rylaarsdam , a 31-year-old OnlyFans content creator, has been charged with second-degree murder following a fetish-themed encounter that resulted in the death of 56-year-old Michael Dale . The event took place on April 17, 2023, at Dale's home.

Details of the Encounter

According to police reports, Dale had contacted Rylaarsdam expressing his desire for a BDSM experience, involving specific practices such as having his legs wrapped in saran wrap and applying glue to various parts of his body, including his eyes. Dale, who appeared intoxicated, had also had women's boots glued to his feet and, at one point, a bag placed over his head secured with duct tape for about eight minutes.

Aftermath of the Incident

The encounter took a tragic turn when Dale became unresponsive, prompting Rylaarsdam to call for medical assistance. He was quickly taken to the hospital but was declared brain dead the next day and later died after being taken off life support.

Evidence and Legal Proceedings

Further investigation uncovered multiple videos and text messages on Rylaarsdam's phone that detailed the encounter. These included texts from Dale outlining his specific fetish requests and videos showing him bound and unresponsive. Despite this documentation, Rylaarsdam, who has entered a plea of not guilty, denied placing or securing the bag over Dale's head. Her attorney, David Cohen , stressed the consensual nature of their meeting and argued that there was no intent to kill.

Rylaarsdam remains incarcerated without bail and awaits a court hearing scheduled for next week.

Implications of Consent and Intent

This case has captivated public and legal interest due to its disturbing details and the significant roles that consent and intent play in legally defining outcomes in cases involving fatal outcomes in consensual fetish activities.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

• • •
Carla Rosa, based in Madison, Wisconsin, is RhyteIt’s go-to expert in social media monetization for adult content creators. With extensive experience in digital monetization and a deep understanding of creator platforms, Carla empowers creators to maximize their earning potential through strategic social media approaches. Her expertise helps creators turn engagement into revenue, develop sustainable income streams, and unlock new monetization opportunities tailored to the unique landscape of adult content.