Natalie Reynolds Investigation - Controversial Bathwater Sales on OnlyFans

Image
Courtney Cashan
Updated 10:32 PM, October 07, 2025

Natalie Reynolds Faces Investigation Over Bathwater Sales

OnlyFans creator Natalie Reynolds has come into the spotlight following an investigation triggered by her recent initiative to sell her bathwater to fans. Reynolds announced the sale through an online video, describing the product as "a ritual in a jar." The bathwater, which was offered at $49.99 per vial, quickly sold out within an hour.

Product Details and Website Information

Reynolds marketed the vials of red-tinted water on her website, BloodyMaryBath.com . The product was clearly marked as not for consumption and carried disclaimers indicating that it had not been evaluated by the FDA. She emphasized that the water was "filtered for purity," "charged under the full moon," and infused with "divine feminine energy."

Reynolds' Response to Criticism

Facing significant backlash, Reynolds, who boasts over 5.5 million subscribers on YouTube and more than 2.2 million followers on TikTok, labeled the criticism as "ridiculous" and defended her actions as a form of artistic expression. “The internet is trying to cancel me once again, so I'm here to defend myself. All I’m doing is giving away a piece of art to my loyal supporters so they feel like they can have a connection with me,” she asserted.

Previous Disputes and Economic Motivations

During her defense, Reynolds also touched upon previous disputes with the Bop House, a content creator mansion, where she accused them of taking 80% of her OnlyFans earnings. “If anyone has anything bad to say about me, it's pretty obvious that you're just jealous of me, and that's your problem, not mine," she stated, addressing her critics directly.

Moreover, she highlighted the economic reasoning behind her controversial decision, stating, “we all need to make money and we all have bills to pay, so mind your business.” The exact details of the ongoing investigation remain undisclosed, along with specific allegations against her.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

Courtney Cashan, based in Columbus, Ohio, is a digital content creation expert at RhyteIt, specializing in the unique needs of adult content creators. With a keen eye for impactful storytelling and high-quality visuals, Courtney helps creators develop engaging, on-brand content that captivates audiences and strengthens their online presence. Her skills empower creators to expand their reach, optimize content strategies, and elevate the quality of their digital offerings to connect authentically with their audience.