Florida's OnlyFans Sin Tax Controversy: Fishback's Proposal and Lacey's Opposition

Image
Hyun Shin
Updated 10:34 PM, January 14, 2026

OnlyFans Sin Tax Proposal Sparks Controversy in Florida

Florida gubernatorial candidate James Fishback has ignited controversy with his proposal to implement a 50% tax on earnings from digital content platforms like OnlyFans. The Republican candidate, who is 31 years old, stated his intention to impose what he terms an "OnlyFans Sin Tax" as a measure to combat what he describes as "online degeneracy." Fishback projects that the tax could generate approximately $200 million annually, which he proposes to allocate towards enhancing teacher salaries and improving school lunches.

OnlyFans Creator Anya Lacey Challenges Proposed Tax

Anya Lacey, a 19-year-old OnlyFans content creator who promotes conservative and traditional wife values, has expressed strong opposition to the tax initiative. On her Instagram account, Lacey criticized the proposal as biased and misguided. She highlighted that unlike other industries perceived as vice-related, such as alcohol, marijuana, and strip clubs, digital content creation on platforms like OnlyFans is being singled out for punitive taxation.

Disparities in Public Perception and Content Diversity

Lacey also addressed the broader societal attitudes towards adult content by pointing out the significant consumption of pornography among U.S. adults. Citing statistics, she noted that 57% of U.S. adults have viewed pornography, with 27% admitting to engaging with such content in the past month. Furthermore, Lacey underscored the diversity of her OnlyFans posts, which range from non-explicit material such as fishing and baking videos to interactions with pets.

Raised Concerns Over Moral Judgement and Tax Inconsistency

By advocating against the proposed tax, Lacey emphasized that the measure not only seems unjust but also reflects subjective moral judgment. She questioned the inconsistency in tax application among various industries, calling for a reevaluation of how digital content creators are treated in comparison to other sectors.

Both Fishback’s tax proposal and Lacey’s response have highlighted ongoing debates over the regulation and taxation of digital content creation. This dispute underscores the complex intersections of entrepreneurship, self-expression, and societal values, as online platforms and the content created through them continue to evolve and spark legislative attention.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

Hyun Shin is a Boston-based reporter for RhyteIt, specializing in personal empowerment strategies for adult content creators. Through insightful articles and resources, Shin helps creators develop confidence, resilience, and self-advocacy skills to thrive on platforms like OnlyFans and Fansly. Shin’s work supports creators in building authentic, empowered personal brands and navigating the challenges unique to the adult content industry.