Exploring the Dark Side of OnlyFans: Exploitation and Legal Concerns

Image
Carla Rosa
Updated 10:36 AM, September 18, 2025

Exploring the Dark Side of OnlyFans: Exploitation Issues Surface

OnlyFans, a content-sharing platform launched in 2016, is renowned for its direct payment model that allows creators to earn from their followers. The service spans across various genres, including fitness and adult entertainment. Despite providing substantial earning opportunities with top creators reportedly making around $80,000 monthly, many average participants face undue exploitation under the management of some profiteering male managers.

Discrepancy Between Earnings and Exploitation

With a user base exceeding 300 million and more than 4 million content creators, OnlyFans generates over $5 billion annually. However, contrary to the potential for high earnings, the average creator on the platform garners just 21 subscribers, with monthly earnings ranging from $110 to $130, a sum significantly below minimum wage standards.

Alarm over Coercive Managerial Practices

Reports of fraud, emotional abuse, and potential illegal activities have surfaced, unveiling the troubling involvement of certain managers who dominate financially insecure female creators. These figures force creators to produce increasingly explicit content, sometimes crossing the boundaries of consent and comfort. Such practices can escalate to coercive control where creators face threats of exposure to intimate images or are pushed into undesired sexual acts.

High-Profile Cases and Legal Implications

Andrew Tate, a controversial figure, is one notable example who allegedly managed numerous women under dubious conditions, significantly profiting from their involvement in the adult industry. The methods adopted by such managers might constitute violations of the UK's Sexual Offences Act 2003 and the Modern Slavery Act 2015, pointing to possible charges of coercion, trafficking, and exploitation.

Digital Platforms' Role and Policy Advocacy

Platforms like OnlyFans, while initiating several safeguarding measures, still face challenges in thorough enforcement. The use of secretive online forums and encrypted services like Telegram for managing and commodifying content highlights a severe concern over the exploitation and manipulation of women. Advocacy groups such as Refuge and End Violence Against Women call for substantial policy changes and platform accountability to combat these systemic abuses.

Need for Systemic Reform

The issues plaguing OnlyFans reflect broader concerns of technology-facilitated abuse, underscoring an urgent need for legal and systemic reforms. The platform's scenario emphasizes the critical role of digital providers in protecting individuals from exploitation and ensuring the ethical management of content in the increasingly monetized digital landscape.

Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter

📬 Get the latest tips, tricks, and updates for professional adult content creators.

• • •
Carla Rosa, based in Madison, Wisconsin, is RhyteIt’s go-to expert in social media monetization for adult content creators. With extensive experience in digital monetization and a deep understanding of creator platforms, Carla empowers creators to maximize their earning potential through strategic social media approaches. Her expertise helps creators turn engagement into revenue, develop sustainable income streams, and unlock new monetization opportunities tailored to the unique landscape of adult content.